IPCRIME NEWSROOM | NOVEMBER 17, 2026
A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of charges arising from a 2023 Ethereum trading strategy that prosecutors said extracted $25 million in roughly 12 seconds. Judge Jessica Clarke’s November 16 ruling followed an earlier trial that ended without a unanimous verdict. The decision turns on whether prosecutors demonstrated material misrepresentations, not on a general endorsement of the trading activity.
What prosecutors alleged
The government charged the two brothers in 2024, arguing that they manipulated a vulnerability or feature in software used by Ethereum validators to induce automated trading bots into losing a large amount of cryptocurrency. Prosecutors characterized the conduct as a deceptive scheme. The brothers disputed that it constituted criminal wire fraud, and their first trial ended in a jury deadlock in 2025.
The judge’s reasoning
According to Reuters and reporting on the decision, Judge Clarke found the transactions did not include the material false statements or representations required for the charged fraud theory. The court rejected a theory that ordinary expectations about how a validator would process transactions necessarily supplied the missing deception. That is a legal ruling about the charged offenses and evidence, not proof that every form of similar MEV manipulation is permissible.
Why this is important
The case tests how fraud laws apply when decentralized protocols, trading bots and validators interact without the contractual and regulatory framework typical of traditional financial markets. Advocates for open blockchain systems have argued that novel software behavior should not automatically become criminal fraud without established false representations; prosecutors had argued the defendants intentionally exploited other traders.
What the outcome does not decide
The acquittal is not a cybersecurity patch, and it does not establish that the defendants’ actions were ethically sound or incapable of violating other laws. It resolves the charges addressed by the ruling. Any appeal, later litigation or collateral proceedings would need separate reporting.
A reporting distinction
IPCRIME previously covered criminal accusations and investigations in other cybercrime cases. This outcome is a reminder that accusations, technical activity, convictions and acquittals are different events, and a fair newsroom must follow a case through its actual legal resolution.
Sources and supporting documents
This is original IPCRIME reporting based on the cited disclosures and research. Dates of the underlying incident, initial announcement and this article are not necessarily the same. Unresolved findings and allegations are explicitly attributed.
